Consistent with theory, we find that stocks with high sensitivities to innovations in aggregate volatility have low average returns. The shape of the volatility smirk has significant cross sectional predictive power for future equity returns. Media coverage and the crosssection of stock returns 2027 volatility with respect to the famafrench 1993 threefactor model exhibit abysmally low returns. Out of sample forecasts from fm regressions provide a simple, yet surprisingly effective, way to form a composite trading strategy going long high expected return stocks. Hundreds of papers and factors attempt to explain the cross section of expected returns. The crosssection of volatility and expected returns request pdf. Apr 05, 2005 we examine how volatility risk, both at the aggregate market and individual stock level, is priced in the cross section of expected stock returns. Crosssectional volatility and stock returns sage journals. Given this extensive data mining, it does not make sense to use the usual criteria for establishing. Idiosyncratic volatility, growth options, and the crosssection of returns this version. However, since that time, hundreds of papers have tried to explain the cross. This paper examines the pricing of volatility risk and idiosyncratic volatility in the cross section of corporate bond returns for the period of 19942016. The empirical results show that the cross section returns have a monotonic decreasing trend with the increasing of idiosyncratic volatility indicators, that confirms the puzzle exists on the. French abstract two easily measured variables, size and book tomarket equity, combine to capture the crosssectional variation in average stock returns associated with market 3, size, leverage, book tomarket equity, and earningsprice ratios.
The crosssection of volatility and expected returns nber. In the crosssectional regressions, the product of marketto book and idiosyncratic volatility is negative and strongly signi cant. The pattern of volatility risks across longperiod portfolios sorted on book tomarket, dividendtoprice, earningstoprice and cash. Given that so many papers have attempted to explain the same crosssection of expected returns, statistical inference should not be based on a single test perspective.
High idiosyncratic volatility and low returns columbia business. The role of investor attention and risk preferences. The crosssection of volatility and expected returns. The crosssection of volatility and expected returns rice university. Volatilityofvolatility and the crosssection of option returns. Media coverage and the crosssection of stock returns. Market frictions, price delay, and the crosssection of expected returns abstract we parsimoniously characterize the severity of market frictions a. Jagannathan and runkle 1993, the question of how aggregate volatility affects the cross section of expected stock returns has received less attention. We follow the fama and french 1992 cross sectional regression procedure and show that each of the 4 monthly measures of change of total volatility, total volatility, expected idiosyncratic variance, and expected idiosyncratic volatility is a negative priced factor in the cross sectional variation of stock returns. However, in portfolios simultaneously sorted on both cashflow and return volatilities, and in cross sectional regressions of returns at the firm level, these two effects neither drive out nor dominate each other. The results indicate that i the data frequency used to estimate idiosyncratic volatility, ii the weighting scheme used to compute average portfolio returns, iii the breakpoints utilized to sort stocks into quintile portfolios, and iv using a screen for size, price, and liquidity. Motivated by the additional existing evidence that investors have a preference for lotterylike assets, i. Adrian and rosenberg 2006 decompose the stock market volatility into a short and a longrun components and show that they explain di.
This paper examines the cross sectional relation between idiosyncratic volatility and expected stock returns. The cross section of expected stock returns 3 available at the time i. First, we cross sectionally estimate a price of risk. There are several advantages of using a cross section of returns on stocks, rather than a cross section of options on the market, to estimate the price of risk of aggregate volatility. Our results are closely related to the recent work by amaya, christo ersen, jacobs, and vasquez acjv 2016, and their nding of signi cant spreads in the weekly returns. We also examine the crosssectional implications of volatility risks for returns on portfolios hold more than one period. Cross section of expected returns and extreme returns. Size, booktomarket, momentum, and liquidity effects cannot account for either.
Investor sentiment and the crosssection of stock returns. The crosssection of volatility and expected returns book. Our goal is to provide guidance as to the appropriate significance level using a multiple testing framework. The crosssection of volatility and expected returns by andrew.
The crosssection of volatility and expected returns ideasrepec. Finally, using the crosssection allows us to estimate the price of volatility risk control. Size, book tomarket, momentum, and liquidity effects cannot account for either the low average returns earned by stocks with high exposure to systematic volatility risk or for the low average returns of stocks with high idiosyncratic volatility. Idiosyncratic volatility and the cross section of expected. Abstract we examine the pricing of aggregate volatility risk in the cross section of stock returns. In the first phase, their goal was to determine the price of aggregate volatility risk in the cross section of expected stock returns, while in the second phase, they studied the cross sectional relationship between idiosyncratic volatility and expected. The cross section of volatility and expected returns. Each author name for a columbia business school faculty member is linked to a faculty research page, which lists additional publications by that faculty member. Andrew ang, robert hodrick, yuhang xing and xiaoyan zhang. However, in portfolios simultaneously sorted on both cash. Consumption volatility and the crosssection of stock returns. First, using the cross section of returns allows us to create a useful hedging, or mimicking factor portfolio for aggregate volatility risk.
The crosssection of volatility and expected returns by. September 20 abstract the paper shows that the value e ect and the idiosyncratic volatility discount ang et al. G12 abstract motivated by existing evidence of a preference among investors for assets with lotterylike payoffs. To the best of my knowledge, i am the first to examine whether uncertainty about an individual stocks volatility is priced in the cross section of option returns. No 10852, nber working papers from national bureau of economic research, inc. Request pdf the crosssection of volatility and expected returns we. We find that media coverage is positively related to both analyst forecast dispersion and idiosyncratic volatility, after controlling. Size, booktomarket, momentum, and liquidity effects cannot. The crosssection of volatility and expected returns, 2006. Pdf volatility and the crosssection of corporate bond. Jan 20, 2006 this phenomenon cannot be explained by exposure to aggregate volatility risk. Stocks that have past high sensitivities to innovations in aggregate volatility have low average returns. We examine how volatility risk, both at the aggregate market and individual stock level, is priced in the cross section of expected stock returns.
Cross section of volatility and expected returns 261 of assets that may have different exposures to aggregate volatility and hence different average returns. We examine the pricing of aggregate volatility risk in the cross section of stock returns. Timevarying market volatility induces changes in the investment opportunity set by changing the expectation of future market returns, or by changing the riskreturn tradeoff. Stocks as lotteries and the cross section of expected returns turan g. Request pdf the cross section of volatility and expected returns we examine the pricing of aggregate volatility risk in the cross section of stock returns.
Adding the product ips the signs of idiosyncratic volatility and marketto book. Stocks exhibiting the steepest smirks in their traded options underperform stocks with the least pronounced volatility smirks in their options by 10. While considerable research has examined the timeseries relation between the volatility of the market and the expected return on the market see, among others, campbell and hentschel 1992 and glosten, jagannathan, and runkle 1993, the question of how aggregate volatility affects the cross section of expected stock returns has received. We nd evidence of a signi cant negative premium for exposure to dispersion risk, where expected returns vary. The empirical results support the theoretical prediction of dispersion being priced in the cross section of stock returns. This phenomenon cannot be explained by exposure to aggregate volatility risk. Size, booktomarket, momentum, and liquidity effects cannot account for either the low average returns. The crosssection of volatility and expected returns semantic. In the first phase, their goal was to determine the price of aggregate volatility risk in the cross section of expected stock returns, while in the second phase, they studied the cross sectional relationship between idiosyncratic volatility and expected returns. Section of volatility and expected returns econpapers.
Section of volatility and expected returns ang 2006. However, formatting rules can vary widely between applications and fields of interest or study. The crosssection of expected stock returns eugene f. Crosssection of expected returns and extreme returns. We provide a systematic study of how stochastic volatility is priced in the cross section of expected stock returns. Pdf the crosssection of volatility and expected returns. Market frictions, price delay, and the crosssection of. If aggregate volatility is a risk factor that is orthogonal to existing risk factors, the sensitivity of stocks.
875 929 92 1179 1255 1094 1025 1370 291 1455 903 159 1240 1099 1190 900 386 1533 241 1315 785 1049 383 562 1401 409 768 230 647 864 81